Captive Insurance Agents - How to Keep Your Head Above Water in This Economy

When I was young I played baseball. I remember one game when we had the bases loaded and I had just come up to bat. It was a hot, sunny day in Houston and the pitcher had his back to the sun so I was squinting just to see him. Just before he pitched, my coach shouted something that became a life lesson for me, "Keep Your Eye on the Ball!"

Now for my own pride, I'm not going to tell you how that game played out, but I will tell you what brought that memory to mind. In a consultation the other day with a long-time client, I stumbled across an interesting discovery that jogged my memory. As he and I were working through a few of the issues in his agency, we inevitably got into a conversation about the economy.

READ ALSO:   Which Auto Insurance Is Best For Young Adults

We talked quite a bit about all of the recent moves in the financial industry and about how it would effect things at Allstate, Farmers and "good neighbor" agents. We talked about the companies of course, but much more important for the agent on the street.

The hard working who isn't afraid to get out there and put his head down and work his tail off for a living, but that doesn't want to spin his wheels forever or try to push a rock uphill - How is that agent effected by the current economy?

As my client and I talked we came up with a few answers, but one in particular kept coming up: in a slowdown, it's incredibly easy for all of us as entrepreneurs to fall into the same old business-as-usual, survival mentality. There are even more things than usual to take our focus off of growing a hugely successful agency.

Now, this might not seem like a huge discovery, but it was amazing to learn that this opportunity to "take your eye off the ball" happens in every field and industry, not just insurance. But the response I've seen from my most successful clients has been the same: they implement better processes to get and keep clients and they stop wasting money and what doesn't work.

Here are the top marketing tips these agents have used:

1. If you have a few small ads you use, print them on postcards and mail them out. Put a good headline at the top to demand their attention. A good postcard can generate a flood of sales leads for a small cost, and as a bonus you can mail the same number of different postcards to determine which ad is best, so you get new leads and also can spend your print ad dollars more effectively.

2. Send a second offer to new clients right after they become clients. One classy way this can be done is with a thank you call or handwritten thank you note giving them the opportunity to meet with you to discuss financial products, and offering them a small Starbucks gift card in exchange for the appointment.

3. Newsletters. It costs up to six times more to make a sale to a new client than to an existing one. If you use newsletters to build relationship with existing clients and occasionally include a sales letter to up sell them to multiple policies or financial products you can hugely increase your profit for client as well as the length of time they'll stay with your agency. Print newsletters are the best but at a minimum e-newsletters are a must.

4. Seminars and Open Houses have long been a staple of the traditional financial services industry. Nearly all financial planners grow their practices this way. An event is a great way to gain face time with clients to keep retention high as well as a great opportunity to bring in prospects either that you have brought with your marketing or referrals from existing clients. (If there is enough reason for your clients to want to come, you can even make them bring a friend in order to come). Limit seating and make people RSVP to give the impression of value. "Come and Go as You Please" doesn't position you well and often limits turnout.


Captive Insurance Agents - How to Keep Your Head Above Water in This Economy

Post a Comment

0 Comments